A lead, a referral or a regulatory risk?

21 October 2026 191
The judgment Raspberry Academy (Proprietary) Limited v Oaksure Financial Services (Proprietary) Limited (2025/219635) [2026] ZAGPJHC 388 (14 April 2026) ("Raspberry Academy judgment") highlights the regulatory risks associated with lead generation models in the financial services industry. The matter concerned a claim for allegedly outstanding commission arising from a referral agreement under which The Raspberry Academy (Pty) Ltd marketed insurance products, referred prospective customers to Oaksure Financial Services (Pty) Ltd, and earned remuneration linked to premiums generated from successful policy sales.

The High Court held that, despite being characterised as a lead referral arrangement, the agreement's substance amounted to the rendering of intermediary services as contemplated in the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act 37 of 2002 ("FAIS Act"). Because Raspberry Academy was neither an authorised financial services provider nor an appointed representative, the court found the agreement to be illegal and unenforceable.

Importantly, the judgment does not suggest that all lead generation models are illegal. Rather, it confirms that the legality of such arrangements depends on their structure, the nature of the activities performed, and whether they cross the line from simple lead referrals into regulated financial intermediation.

Lead generation has become an important component of modern commerce. Businesses increasingly rely on referral networks and third-party marketers to identify and introduce prospective customers. Within the financial services sector, these arrangements are commonplace and frequently operate under what are commonly described as "lead generation" or "lead referral" models.

At first glance, a lead generation arrangement appears straightforward. A business identifies potential customers and refers them to a financial services provider in exchange for a referral fee or other remuneration. However, the regulatory position becomes more complex where compensation is linked to successful transactions and where the referring party actively markets or promotes financial products.

The Raspberry Academy judgment grapples directly with these complexities and has renewed attention on an important question: when does lead generation remain a marketing activity, and when does it become a regulated intermediary service requiring authorisation under the FAIS Act?

What is a lead generation model?
A lead generation model is a business arrangement in which one party identifies and refers prospective customers to another business. Typically, the lead generator sources customer details, obtains consent to share those details, introduces prospective customers to a service provider, and receives compensation for the referral.

Compensation structures vary considerably. Some lead generators receive:

  • a fixed fee per lead;
  • a fee for appointments secured; or
  • remuneration linked to successful sales or revenue generated from referred customers.

While lead generation is widely accepted across many industries, financial services remain subject to extensive regulation aimed at protecting consumers. Consequently, the legality of a lead generation arrangement depends not on how it is labelled, but on the substance of the activities performed.

The Raspberry Academy dispute
The dispute arose when The Raspberry Academy (Pty) Ltd instituted legal proceedings against Oaksure Financial Services (Pty) Ltd for approximately R1.2 million allegedly owing under a lead referral agreement concluded in 2019.

Under the agreement, Raspberry Academy generated and referred prospective clients to Oaksure, marketed Oaksure's short-term insurance products, obtained customer consent for contact by Oaksure, and received remuneration linked to premiums generated from successful referrals. Its entitlement to referral fees continued for as long as the underlying insurance policies remained active and premiums were paid.

The matter came before the High Court as an application for default judgment after Oaksure failed to defend the action.

The central issue before the Court was whether Raspberry Academy was merely providing lead generation and marketing services, or whether its activities constituted "intermediary services" as defined in the FAIS Act.

The Court considered section 7 of the FAIS Act, which prohibits a person from acting as a financial services provider unless authorised by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority, as well as section 13, which regulates the appointment of representatives. The Court also examined the statutory definition of an intermediary service: any act that results in a client entering into, offering to enter into, or potentially entering into a transaction relating to a financial product with a product supplier.

Although the agreement described Raspberry Academy as a "marketing agent and lead referrer", the Court emphasised that substance rather than form was determinative. It found that:

  • Raspberry Academy's remuneration was directly linked to the successful conclusion and continuation of insurance policies;
  • it actively marketed insurance products;
  • it facilitated customer engagement with Oaksure; and
  • its activities had a direct causal connection to the conclusion of insurance transactions.

On this basis, the Court held that Raspberry Academy's conduct fell within the scope of intermediary services contemplated in the FAIS Act. Because it was neither an authorised financial services provider under section 7 nor an appointed representative under section 13, the agreement was illegal and unenforceable. The court therefore dismissed the application for default judgment.

Are Lead Generation Models legal?
The key question arising from the judgment is whether lead generation models remain lawful in the financial services sector.

The answer is yes, provided that the arrangement is properly structured.

The Raspberry Academy judgment should not be interpreted as rendering all lead generation models unlawful. On the contrary, the judgment indicates that not every act associated with a referral will necessarily constitute an intermediary service; rather, the nature and substance of the activities performed must be considered to determine whether the FAIS Act applies.

A lead generation model is more likely to be permissible where the lead generator:

  • is paid a fixed fee per lead;
  • does not market or promote specific financial products;
  • does not influence customer decisions;
  • does not provide advice or recommendations; and
  • plays no role beyond introducing prospective customers to the financial services provider.

Conversely, regulatory concerns arise where:

  • remuneration is linked to successful transactions, premiums or commissions;
  • the lead generator actively markets financial products;
  • customer purchasing decisions are influenced or facilitated; or
  • activities directly contribute to the conclusion of financial product transactions.

In these circumstances, the arrangement may constitute a regulated intermediary service requiring authorisation under section 7 of the FAIS Act or appointment as a representative under section 13.

The Raspberry Academy judgment does not invalidate all lead generation models in the financial services sector. Instead, it reminds businesses that they must carefully structure referral arrangements to ensure they do not cross the line into regulated intermediary activity, unless the lead generator is appropriately authorised or appointed in accordance with the FAIS Act.

The judgment further reinforces a longstanding regulatory principle: courts and regulators will look at the substance of an arrangement rather than the label attached to it. Simply describing an agreement as a "lead referral agreement" will not prevent the application of the FAIS Act where the activities performed bear the hallmarks of intermediary services.

For financial institutions, insurers, brokers and marketing businesses, the lesson is clear. Where remuneration and business activities are directly linked to the successful conclusion of financial product transactions, the arrangement may fall within the ambit of the FAIS Act, carrying significant consequences for both its legality and enforceability.


Disclaimer: This article is the personal opinion/view of the author(s) and does not necessarily present the views of the firm. The content is provided for information only and should not be seen as an exact or complete exposition of the law. Accordingly, no reliance should be placed on the content for any reason whatsoever, and no action should be taken on the basis thereof unless its application and accuracy have been confirmed by a legal advisor. The firm and author(s) cannot be held liable for any prejudice or damage resulting from action taken based on this content without further written confirmation by the author(s).

Related Sectors: Wealth Management
Share: